Reported Jul 10, 2024 · Terminated

Red Button Vintage Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Net weight 1.75 qt (1.66 L).

Casper's Ice Cream, Inc.

Moderate riskThis product could cause temporary or reversible health problems — stop using it.

What you should do

Stop using the affected lot and contact the recalling firm for the return or refund process. Check the FDA enforcement report for lot-level detail.

Firm contact: Casper's Ice Cream, Inc · 11805 N 200 E · Richmond, UT · 84333-1408

Is this the product you have?

  • Red Button Vintage Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Net weight 1.75 qt (1.66 L).
Lot codes and dates
  • lot number 092-24-568 UPC0 77865 01008 6
Amount recalled
13,764 tubs - 1.75 qt (1.88 L) per unit

Where it was sold

Why it was recalled

Foreign object, rubber, found in two tubs of Red Button Vintage Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream.

This product could cause temporary or reversible health problems — stop using it.

Want the full recall guide?

The guide adds the identifying codes laid out for scanning, symptoms to watch for, a timeline, and news coverage of this recall.

Free recall alerts

Get alerted about new dairy recalls

One email when a matching recall is published. No account, no cost, unsubscribe in one click.

Where this came from

Source: U.S. Food & Drug Administration (openFDA)

Read the FDA (openFDA food enforcement) notice

Notice updated Jul 11, 2025 · Data as of Sep 19, 6:36 PM UTC

RecallNow is not a government agency. Every fact on this page is published by the FDA, USDA or CPSC and links back to their notice.